by W. J Mencarow, Jr., president of The Paper Source, Inc.
No.
The American Cash Flow Association ( ACFA ), the Diversified Cash Flow Institute ( DCFI ), Global Resource Network and several others -- whatever name they go by, in the last few years the suede shoe and pinky ring crowd have shown up selling note "seminars" and "boot camps" on TV infomercials, in slick magazines and mass mailings, promising people that notes are the sure path to riches. They essentially tell people: "The note business is easy." "THERE'S NO COMPETITION." (The Diversified Cash Flow Institute, the biggest cash flow seminar sales company actually puts this in big letters across the screen in their infomercial! In case you didn't know, that is an outright lie. There's a LOT of competition in the note business.) Other claims frequently made: "Many of our graduates make over $100,000 a year." "You can spend all day on the golf course when you're a note broker, just take your cel phone, make a couple of calls, and boom! You've made $10,000!"
They charge anywhere from $5,000 to $10,000 for a few days of "training," (which tells you why they think notes are the sure path to riches - their own!). To sweeten the pot, you receive the bogus title of "certified note investor" or something similar when you take their course. The fact is, there is no certification recognized by the note industry. One "certification agency" is in the same building as the note seminar company (and in fact was created by the same people). It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out what's going on.
NEWSWEEK sent a reporter to take the complete $5,995 course offered by the
Diversified Cash Flow Institute (DCFI), run by Larry Pino, who also runs the American Cash
Flow Association. They heard one of the DCFI pitchmen say "I'll show you
how to make $1,000 with one phone call" if you take the course. According to
the June 8 story:
"We waited 15 months to give Pino's students time to put their pricey lessons to
work. Then we asked them how many $1,000 phone calls they'd made. Zero, as far as we can
learn...
Of the 32 people in that class, 15 months later "some couldn't be found for a
follow-up, others didn't answer (the reporter's) calls. Of the 18 who replied, only one
had any deals -- two small ones that paid $300 and $750."
(To learn more about the note business without having your pockets picked, go to The Note Buyer's Dollar Store and The Profit Center.)
Below is a summary of the Jane Bryant Quinn NEWSWEEK article.
The Federal Trade Commission is also going after the seminar pitchmen. There have been a lot of complaints made to state regulators by people who feel they were ripped off by the note seminars. It's only a matter of time before their house of cards collapses around them. Unfortunately, in the meantime they are getting rich by preying on people's dreams.
One of these days you'll see them on another TV channel -- no, not their infomercials, this time they'll be on "60 Minutes" covering their faces and running away from Mike Wallace.
The note business got more publicity than it has ever had in its history in the June 8, 1998 issue of Newsweek and 154 major newspapers across the United States.
The most well-known and respected personal finance expert in the country, Jane Bryant Quinn, wrote about the note industry in a two-page Newsweek story. The article was also syndicated in her column to 154 major newspapers.
It has become the hottest topic in the industry.
Why is this so significant? A published story, especially one in Newsweek and all the major newspapers, becomes part of the permanent record. One of the first things a reporter does when beginning to work on a story is to do a computer search for everything already published on the subject. From now on, this story will pop up. Its part of our industrys (and Larry Pinos) permanent file. Whatever the public reads or sees on TV about the note business will be influenced by that story.
How did our business attract the attention of the national news media? Was it because it is so unique and relatively unknown? Because it offers people financing they could not get otherwise? Because it is one of the fastest-growing sectors of the financial world? No, no and no.
It caught the eye of Newsweek because of an outfit known as the Diversified Cash Flow Institute (DCFI also known as D.C.F.I.), run by an Orlando lawyer named Larry Pino. DCFI sells a class on how to be a note broker for $5,995 through highly-visible national TV infomercials, 4-page glossy ads in major airline magazines, massive direct mail campaigns and sales meetings across the country.
The Newsweek article is headlined,
That headline is restrained compared to the ones in newspapers across the country: "Get Rich Course Will Waste Your $6,000" (Philadelphia); "Keep Eye On Pitch To Get Rich" (Akron); "Grim Reality Lurks Behind Sales Pitch" (Washington State); "Discounted Notes Latest in Get-Rich-Quick Parade" (Ft. Lauderdale); "Road To Riches With "Discounted Notes" May Be Rocky" (Orlando) and many, many others.
"Spiel Feeds Dreams"
Newsweek reporter Temma Ehrenfeld, along with 450 others, attended a "free seminar" in New York City sponsored by DCFI. The magazine said the DCFI pitchman spewed "a spiel that feeds dreams. 'I'll show you how to make $1,000 with one phone call,' he cries. 'You deserve to be making three times as much as you're making now.' He claimed that you could make '$4,900 a month for a few hours' work: $128,367 on your maiden deal.' All this without leaving home."
The price of this dream? Just $5,995 ($2,495 for the tape course).
Newsweek paid the fee and sent Ms. Ehrenfeld to the live course. Then they waited 15 months to find out how her fellow students had done:
"We asked them how many $1,000 phone calls they'd made. Zero, as far as we can learn."
After 15 months she could find only ONE of her 32 DCFI classmates (of the 18 who responded) who had made any money at all: One deal for a profit of $750, and one for $300.
$750 + $300 = $1050. The most successful student she could find is in the hole for $4,945.00 18 months later (the cost of the class minus the $1050 profit).
$5,995 x 32 students = $191,840 for DCFI.
Quinn reported on two DCFI students (not in the above class) who said they were happy with their training.
Past Associations
Newsweek says Pino's past business experience has "not always (been) in the best of company. He first lectured for (and represented, as a real estate lawyer), huckster Charles J. Givens, who ran some dubious financial-planning organizations.
Here's what John T. Reed says about Givens. Reed is a graduate of Harvard (M.B.A.) and West Point, has authored several excellent books on real estate finance and writes Real Estate Investors Monthly. (Reeds comments are reprinted by permission from his guru-rating page www.johntreed.com/Reedgururating.html )
"If you look up "glib" in the dictionary, you'll find a picture of Givens next to the definition. Givens is the Cliff Claven of finance. His International Administrative Services, Inc., which did business under 16 names including some involved in real estate, went bankrupt in Orlando in the summer of 1996.
"In 1995, the Florida Attorney General got Givens to agree to pay $377,000 to cover refunds and the cost of the Florida investigation. Givens also agreed to stop making certain claims about the value of his teachings and to make full refunds to anyone who requests them within three days of receiving his materials. Two juries found him guilty of fraud.
"The Wisconsin State Bureau of Consumer Protection published a Guide for Wisconsin TV stations which lists several "Questionable infomercials," among them those of Charles J. Givens."
NEWSWEEK: In 1993 and again in 1996, juries decided that Givens had committed fraud.
"Among Pino's other stops were seminars run by Mark Haroldsen, charged by the Federal Trade Commission in 1996 with selling home business "starter kits" deceptively (Haroldsen denies it).
REED: "Haroldsen was publisher of the now quarterly Financial Freedom Report. His main claim to fame is that he invented the densely-worded, full-page, magazine, direct-mail ad to sell his book.
"Financial Freedom Report was accused of 83 counts of deceptive sales practices by the Utah Division of Consumer Protection according to a 5/19/97 KLS-TV story in Salt Lake City. Utah had received over 900 complaints about Financial Freedom Report nationwide since 1993 but only took action based on the 83 complaints from Utah residents. KLS-TV said the Commonwealth of Virginia had also taken action against Financial Freedom Report.
"The Wisconsin State Bureau of Consumer Protection published a Guide for Wisconsin TV stations which lists several "Questionable infomercials," among them those of Financial Freedom Report.
Reed says, "Haroldsen's people once called me to ask permission to reprint one of my book chapters as an article in their magazine. I said, "OK, for $375." They said they only paid $125. I said no deal. They went ahead and printed it anyway and sent me a check for $125. I sent them an invoice for $250 and a strongly-worded note. They ignored me. I then told everyone I met who had the slightest interest in Haroldsen about that incident. Many months later, Haroldsen was coming to Monterey, California to give a seminar. I plotted how I could obtain a judgment against him and have the sheriff execute the judgment by till-tapping, that is, seizing his receipts, at the seminar. About that time, he sent me a check for $250. If you'd like to be treated the way he treated me, deal with Mark Haroldsen."
Pino's past also includes a stint with Dave Del Dotto.
NEWSWEEK: "Dave Del Dotto, an earlier popularizer of "cash flow," settled an FTC action in 1996 with a $200,000 fine."
REED: "Del Dotto is a former sheetrocker from Modesto, Ca. who did infomercials featuring himself sitting on the beach in Hawaii. I debated him on Larry King Live.
"Del Dotto strikes me as the dumbest of the famous gurus. In one of the books he sold with his home-study course, he said to take advantage of a Farmers Home Administration loan. If you're not a farmer, he said, get one to "front for you." Many of the other gurus give similar advice. But Del Dotto is the only one I know dumb enough not to understand that the standard, get-rich-quick-guru way to deal with the issue is not to mention the farmer requirement. For the record, getting a farmer to front for you in a loan program that's for farmers only is a felony. Del Dotto's Modesto headquarters was foreclosed in the '90s.
"The Wisconsin State Bureau of Consumer Protection published a Guide for Wisconsin TV stations which lists several "Questionable infomercials," among them those of David Del Dotto.
"In the 6/8/98 Newsweek, Jane Bryant Quinn said that Del Dotto had gone bankrupt."
Newsweek reports that "Pino himself was reprimanded by the Florida Bar Association in 1988 for misusing an investor's funds." Pino says he paid the money back.
The Heart Of The Problem
Jane Bryant Quinn cuts to the heart of the issue:
She then summarizes the key points:
1) "Note brokering isn't as easy as it sounds." In spite of claims to the contrary in order to sell seminars, successful note brokers work 50 to 70 hours a week and couldn't earn a living part-time. A Pino booklet called "Getting Your First 10 Deals In 10 Days or Less" met with "um, disbelief" among seasoned note brokers questioned by Newsweek. Pino says he "barely remembers" what he calls the "broad stroke stuff" booklet.
2) "There's probably not as much money in it as you think." Invoice buyer John Fox says he has to retrain many DCFI graduates and finds most of them "unrealistic..about the opportunities to really make money." Pino says he doesnt teach what Fox requires.
3) "The competition can be brutal. Pino claims that youre up against "limited competition" for deals that are "as plentiful as raindrops." Veteran note broker Ed Burris calls those claims "baloney." He says he had almost 1,000 "brokers" on his contact list. Most did one transaction and disappeared.
4) You need skills. If you are "young or mature," "rich or poor," or "stuck in a dead end job"you ought to be a note broker -- at least if you believe the advertising. Not so, says Dwayne, a Seattle ironworker interviewed by Quinn who was persuaded by Pino's pitchman to borrow money to attend the class. "I was taken advantage of," he says. "It's not for working-class people...You need a background to do this."
Lorelei Stevens, a regular columnist for THE PAPER SOURCE and president of national note investment firm Wall Street Brokers (www.wallstreetbrokers.com), was quoted in Newsweek saying that these skills would help new note brokers: marketing, making public presentations, negotiation, business math, real estate finance and knowledge of the relevant law.
To find out if note brokering is for you, Quinn suggests Jon Richards $65 two-tape lecture and book "How To Start A Discounted Note Business." For more complete training, get the 18-hour tape course "Profits In Discounted Notes," "followed by hands-on courses offered at a fraction of Pino's price."
Quinn concludes, "Pino explains the business, too, but wanna-bes should start small. They're less likely to break their bank accounts, or their hearts."
Those who didnt read the story in Newsweek will read it in their local newspaper, or a friend will send it to them. Theres no doubt that everyone even slightly interested in notes has or will read it.
To read the full text of Jane Bryant Quinn's column on the Diversified Cash Flow Institute ( DCFI ) and Larry Pino, bookmakr this page, then go to http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/business/longterm/quinn/columns/061898.htm
From the Wisconsin State Journal, Sept. 4, 1997
Wisconsin consumer protection officials tried to close the door Wednesday on what they called another "get-rich-quick" seminar in Madison.
Officials served a subpoena to the "Millionaires At Home" seminar sponsors at the Sheraton Hotel in Madison. the subpoena demanded proof of the seminar claims that people can make hundreds of thousands of dollars in a few months, without putting their own money at risk.
It's the second time in three week that Wisconsin Department of Agriculture, Trade and
Consumer Protection officials have served subpoenas to traveling business seminars.
"We are concerned because we see a lot of people who could lose a small fortune at at
these things," said Glen Loyd, consumer protection information officer.
One of Wednesday's seminar organizers recently paid $10,284 in fines and legal
fees for making misleading claims in Tennessee.
Tennessee officials said he used deceptive business tactics. In one instance,
according to Tennessee officials, he claimed someone could earn $500,000 a year
on the telephone using "Diversified Cash Flow Institute" practices.
The Madison seminar attracted about 60 people, Loyd said. Consumer protection
officials handed out cautionary information to about 50 of the seminar participants.
The organizer, and Larry Pino with Diversified Cash Flow Institute, were not
available for comment Wednesday.
If the seminar sponsors fail to answer the state subpoena, they are subject to a $5,000
fine or a year in jail, Loyd said.
"If they come back, at least we have something to grab onto."
Also visit The Note Buyer's Dollar Store and The Profit Center (click on each).
Main Menu The Note Buyer's Dollar Store The Profit Center FAQs Tapes, Courses & Software Sample Issue Subscribe Back Issues Free E-Newsletter Investors Links Link To Us Search